Sarasota Criminal Defense Attorney
Getting an Aggressive Criminal Defense Lawyer Is Your First Priority
If you or a loved one has been arrested in Sarasota, hiring an experienced criminal defense attorney is an important first step toward protecting your rights. A conviction may result in jail or prison time, steep fines, and a criminal record that could make securing a job, obtaining housing, or maintaining a normal life much harder.
At the Law Offices of Eric Reisinger, PA, we have over two decades of experience protecting our clients’ rights and freedom inside and outside the courtroom. As a former prosecutor, Attorney Eric Reisinger understands how the state approaches each case. We use that insight to develop a personalized legal defense and stand ready to represent you at trial when needed.
Call us today at (941) 541-5335 or request a complimentary initial consultation. We serve Sarasota County. Explore our Manatee County criminal defense page.
Types of Criminal Charges We Handle in Sarasota
Our Sarasota criminal defense lawyer handles cases ranging from minor infractions to serious felony charges. Each case requires a strategy based on the facts, the nature of the charge, and the circumstances of the arrest.
We provide strategic defense in cases involving:
- DUI, underage DUI and traffic offenses, such as reckless driving or speeding.
- Drug crimes such as possession, sale, and trafficking.
- Theft, burglary, and other property crimes.
- Domestic violence and restraining order violations.
- Violent crimes such as assault and battery, manslaughter, and homicide.
- White collar offenses such as fraud, embezzlement, and forgery.
- Juvenile delinquency matters.
- Probation violations.
- Federal charges.
- Sex crimes such as prostitution, sexual abuse, and child molestation.
Each type of case presents distinct challenges and opportunities. We analyze the evidence, identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, and pursue the best possible outcome for you.
Potential Penalties of a Criminal Conviction in Florida
Criminal offenses in Florida fall into two main categories: misdemeanors and felonies.
Misdemeanors
Misdemeanors carry jail sentences of up to one year in county jail. Common examples include DUI, marijuana possession, battery, petty theft, and disorderly conduct.
The following are the two types of misdemeanors in Florida:
- First-degree misdemeanor - Jail sentence up to one year and a maximum fine of $1,000
- Second-degree misdemeanor - Maximum jail term of 60 days and a fine up to $500
Felonies
Felonies are more serious and punishable by up to life imprisonment or the death penalty. Examples include murder, sex offenses, most drug crimes (excluding some cannabis cases), kidnapping, burglary, grand theft, aggravated battery, and child abuse.
Felonies in Florida include:
- Capital felony - Life imprisonment without parole or the death penalty
- Life felony - Life imprisonment and a maximum fine of $15,000
- First-degree felony - Up to 30 years in prison and a fine of up to $10,000
- Second-degree felony - Up to 15 years in prison and a fine of up to $10,000
- Third-degree felony - Up to five years in prison and a fine not exceeding $5,000
A conviction can affect eligibility for certain licenses, civil rights, travel, and other aspects of daily life, depending on the offense and individual circumstances. Many jobs in Sarasota involve working with the public or require background checks, including tourism, healthcare, and government roles, making these collateral consequences especially significant here.
We explain the possible short- and long-term effects. We also review whether sealing or expunging your record may be an option, so you can make informed choices about your future employment and housing.
Collateral Consequences
The less visible penalties can be among the most damaging:
- Employment Disqualification: A criminal record can limit eligibility for jobs in healthcare, education, and finance.
- Professional License Suspension: A conviction can lead Florida licensing boards to review or initiate disciplinary proceedings, depending on the profession and offense.
- Immigration Consequences: For non-citizens, a conviction can affect immigration status, admissibility, or eligibility for citizenship, depending on the charge and immigration circumstances.
- Housing Obstacles: Property managers may run background checks, and certain criminal histories can make a housing application more difficult.
How the Florida Criminal Process Works
A Sarasota criminal defense attorney can guide you through each stage, explain your options, and protect your rights as the case develops.
- Investigation: Before charges are filed, law enforcement gathers evidence, interviews witnesses, and may conduct surveillance. If you learn you’re being investigated, involve a Sarasota criminal defense attorney early. Guidance before charges are filed may affect what’s ultimately charged or whether charges are filed.
- Arrest and booking: After an arrest, you’re photographed, fingerprinted, and held until a bond hearing. Your choices at this stage, particularly whether to speak to police, can have a lasting impact. Remain silent and request a lawyer immediately.
- First appearance and bond hearing: Within 24 hours, you see a judge who informs you of the charges and sets conditions for your release. An experienced Sarasota criminal defense lawyer can present information about your background and ties to the area when arguing for fair bond or release terms.
- Arraignment: At arraignment, you enter a plea of guilty, not guilty, or no contest. The court sets discovery and pre-trial dates at this appearance.
- Discovery and pre-trial motions: Your criminal defense attorney reviews prosecution evidence and may file motions to challenge unlawful searches, dismiss unsupported charges, or limit certain testimony.
- Plea negotiations or trial: Many cases resolve through plea agreements, although the outcome depends on the charges, evidence, court rulings, and circumstances. If you don’t accept a plea or choose to go to trial, your lawyer defends you in court, challenges the prosecution’s witnesses, and makes the case for acquittal.
Comprehensive Criminal Defense in Sarasota & Arcadia
When you face criminal charges in Sarasota or Arcadia, you need a defense attorney who knows the local legal landscape. The Law Offices of Eric Reisinger, P.A. understands the procedures of the Sarasota County court system.
Sarasota County felony matters are handled by the Circuit Criminal Division, while misdemeanor and criminal traffic cases are handled in County Court within Florida’s Twelfth Judicial Circuit. We account for the applicable local procedures while reviewing evidence, preparing filings, and responding to developments in your case.
Common Legal Defenses Available
When facing criminal charges in Sarasota, you need strategies designed to challenge the prosecution’s evidence and methods.
- Independent investigation: We don’t rely solely on evidence collected by law enforcement. We conduct our own investigation, interview witnesses, consult with private investigators, and review relevant documentation for evidence that supports your defense.
- Challenging the evidence: We scrutinize how evidence was collected, request calibration records for machines used, and file motions to exclude evidence obtained in violation of your constitutional rights.
- Asserting strong legal defenses: We identify and develop defenses supported by the facts, such as:
- Self-defense: We can argue that your actions were justified based on the circumstances surrounding the alleged use of force.
- Alibi: Evidence may establish that you weren’t at the location when the crime occurred.
- Lack of intent: The evidence may not establish the criminal intent required for the charge.
- Negotiating with prosecutors: We negotiate with the state when doing so serves your defense strategy. Attorney Reisinger’s former-prosecutor experience informs how we evaluate evidence, anticipate prosecution arguments, and pursue case-dependent options such as reduced charges, dismissal, or a plea agreement.
What a Sarasota Criminal Defense Lawyer Provides
A defense attorney examines the case against you, develops a strategy, and advocates for you in negotiations and court.
Here’s what we deliver:
- Thorough case analysis - We examine every detail, regardless of the charge.
- Aggressive pre-trial motions - We challenge unlawful evidence and require the state to prove its case.
- Smart negotiation - We evaluate diversion programs, plea agreements, and reduced charges when those paths are available and consistent with your goals.
- Trial advocacy - We stand ready to defend your case before a jury when needed.
- Open communication - You receive updates and guidance at every step, so you know the status of your case.
Criminal cases in Sarasota require close attention to local rules, including applicable deadlines in the Twelfth Judicial Circuit. We act quickly to gather evidence, interview witnesses, and respond to prosecutors. This approach can keep your case on track and preserve the available defense strategies.
Through membership in criminal defense organizations, we stay informed about legal developments and provide Sarasota clients with reliable, up-to-date guidance.
How to Evaluate Criminal Defense Counsel in Sarasota
Relevant courtroom experience, personal handling of your case, and clear communication should be central to your decision. Attorney Reisinger has handled criminal litigation as an Assistant State Attorney and in private defense representation, giving him experience evaluating charges, evidence, witness accounts, and trial issues from both sides of a prosecution.
Before choosing counsel, ask about:
- Criminal trial experience: Ask whether the attorney has handled misdemeanor and felony trials involving charges similar to yours.
- Personal case responsibility: Confirm who will review the evidence, communicate with you, negotiate with prosecutors, and appear in court.
- Defense planning: Discuss how the attorney develops an individualized strategy from the facts, evidence, and your priorities.
- Fees and scope: Request a clear explanation of the fee arrangement and the work covered by it before retaining counsel.
- Board Certification: Ask whether the attorney holds Florida Bar Board Certification in Criminal Trial Law and verify the current certification through its official directory.
This board certification is the Florida Bar’s highest recognition of competency and experience in Criminal Trial Law. Certification requires at least five years in practice, substantial trial involvement, qualifying contested cases and jury trials, continuing legal education, peer review, and a written examination. It lasts no longer than five years before the attorney must satisfy recertification requirements.
The Right to Counsel & Florida’s Public Defender Process
A person who can’t afford private counsel can apply for appointed representation through the clerk of court. The clerk reviews the application to determine indigent status, and qualifying defendants may receive appointed counsel for felony, misdemeanor, criminal contempt, and other covered proceedings.
As of 2026, Florida requires a $50 application fee, which can’t be waived when an applicant is found indigent. A court can’t appoint counsel in the same case when the defendant has retained a private attorney.
We provide an initial consultation at no charge for prospective clients considering private representation. You can call us or use the contact form to discuss the charges, available documents, upcoming court dates, and the circumstances surrounding the case.
Why Choose Our Firm for Sarasota Criminal Defense
Attorney Eric Reisinger served as an Assistant State Attorney in Sarasota and Manatee Counties after his admission in 2005. We use that former-prosecutor insight to examine how the state built its case, anticipate prosecution arguments, and craft practical, strategic defenses.
Attorney Reisinger earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Criminology from the University of South Florida and graduated from St. Thomas University of Law. He has tried misdemeanor and felony cases ranging from DUIs to armed robberies and murder. He is also a member of the Florida Bar and the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.
Attorney Reisinger successfully argued a motion for immunity under Florida’s Stand Your Ground law in a murder case, resulting in dismissal of the client’s murder charge. That result reflects his experience examining evidence, preparing pretrial motions, and litigating serious criminal charges without broadening what any future case may achieve.
We prioritize clear communication from your first meeting through final resolution, helping you prepare for appearances in Sarasota County. We tailor defense plans to your background, obligations, and long-term concerns, not just the statute.
Don’t let criminal charges dictate your future. Contact Law Offices of Eric Reisinger, PAtoday by calling (941) 541-5335for a free initial consultation and take the first step toward protecting your rights and freedom.
Our Settlements & Verdicts
Recent Case Victories
Our top priority is to devise customized legal strategies that are tailored to the unique legal needs of our clients, no matter how simple or complicated their situations, might be.
-
Not Guilty Verdict 2016 CF 004875 NC – Life Felony Second Degree Murder
-
Not Guilty Verdict 2017 CF 000169 – Life Felony Armed Robbery
-
Successful Resolution 2017 CF 002479 AX – 15 Counts of Possession of Child Pornography
-
Not Guilty Verdict 2017 MM 11498 – Misdemeanor Battery and Misdemeanor Sex Offense -Unnatural and Lascivious Act
-
Case Dismissed 2018 CF 000323 – Two Counts Felony Battery on a Person 65 or Older
-
Case Dismissed 2018 CF 002675 AX–Felony Battery on a Person 65 or Older
-
“I strongly recommend him if you are in need of a defense attorney!”Kathy
-
“Did exactly what they said they would do, was very responsive and helped to resolve my legal issue quickly.”Heather
-
“They were able to amend my charges so that I am no longer a habitual traffic offender and I was able to get my drivers license right away.”Diane
-
“My experience with the Law Office of Eric Reisinger was fantastic!”Talia
-
“I felt like I was talking to some one I could trust, good price ... and I couldn’t be happier with this firm.”Able
-
“If you need legal assistance you have found the right attorney.”Kevin
-
“My experience with attorney, Eric Reisinger was exceptional.”Lisa
-
“If you need legal counsel STOP looking and call Eric Reisinger.”William
Why Choose Law Offices of Eric Reisinger, PA?
-
Former Prosecutor
-
Free Initial Consultation
-
Successful Trial Experience
-
Phone Is Answered 24/7
-
Over Two Decades of Experience
-
Trusted Reputation with Judges & Prosecutors